Is Free Recall Active: The Testing Effect through the ICAP Lens

ID: 49779 Type: Full Paper: Journal Publication
  1. Christiana Bruchok, Arizona State University, United States
  2. Christopher Mar and Scotty D. Craig, Arizona State University , United States

Tuesday, November 15 1:30 PM-2:00 PM Location: Edison C View on map

Presider: Scotty D. Craig, Arizona State University, United States

Abstract: Amidst evidence in favor of “active learning,” online instruction widely implements passive design and tests learners’ retrieval performance as opposed to learners’ understanding. Literature reporting the testing effect promotes recall as a learning tool. The Interactive>Constructive>Active>Passive taxonomy would place quizzing during instruction somewhere on the active learning spectrum since learners manipulate the content in some way. Studying without physical manipulation of the content, the typical comparison group for the testing effect, is inherently passive; therefore, the superiority of testing to studying reflects the superiority of active to passive learning. Tests can elicit an array of engagement behaviors, and ICAP differentiates some as leading to better learning outcomes than others. The present preliminary study found free recall, germane to the testing effect literature and easily implemented in online instruction, to be only an active activity per ICAP criteria.


Conference attendees are able to comment on papers, view the full text and slides, and attend live presentations. If you are an attendee, please login to get full access.